Blue Jays vs. Yankees ALDS Game 3: Odds, Predictions, and Best Bets

TORONTO, October 8, 2025– The American League Division Series takes center stage tonight as the Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees square off in Game 3 at Rogers Centre. With the series tied 1-1, both clubs enter a pivotal showdown that could swing momentum for the rest of the series.

Context & Stakes

The Yankees, powered by their elite pitching staff, managed to even the series in New York, while Toronto relied on timely hitting to steal Game 1. Tonight’s matchup shifts north of the border, where the Blue Jays will enjoy the energy of a packed Canadian crowd.

Oddsmakers currently have the game listed close to a pick’em, with the Yankees’ Gerrit Cole slated to take the mound against Blue Jays ace Kevin Gausman.

What Players & Coaches Are Saying

Yankees manager Aaron Boone stressed the importance of focus on the road:

“We know what Rogers Centre brings in October. It’s loud, it’s passionate. But at the end of the day, it’s about execution.”

Blue Jays skipper John Schneider countered with confidence in his starter:

“Gausman’s been in these spots before. We’re confident in his ability to set the tone early and let our bats do the rest.”

Expert Analysis

Cole vs. Gausman presents a classic pitchers’ duel, but analysts note Toronto’s home-field advantage could tilt the balance. The Blue Jays are 10-2 in their last 12 postseason home games, while the Yankees have historically struggled north of the border in October.

Bettors are eyeing the under on total runs given the strength of both starters. Prop bets on Vladimir Guerrero Jr. driving in a run, or Aaron Judge going deep, have also drawn sharp attention.

Balanced View

While Yankees fans believe Cole’s dominance gives them the edge, Blue Jays supporters point to Toronto’s bullpen depth and offensive versatility. “It’s anyone’s game,” one Toronto fan said outside Rogers Centre this morning. “But we like our chances at home.”

Conclusion & Next Steps

With the series knotted up, tonight’s result could be decisive. The winner of Game 3 in a best-of-five format historically advances more than 70% of the time. Expect a raucous crowd, plenty of nerves, and the possibility of a postseason classic.